SB 1343

Overall Vote Recommendation
Yes
Principle Criteria
positive
Free Enterprise
positive
Property Rights
positive
Personal Responsibility
positive
Limited Government
positive
Individual Liberty
Digest

SB 1343 proposes amendments to Sections 509.004 and 509.005(b) of the Texas Business & Commerce Code to strengthen consumer privacy protections and increase transparency in the data brokerage industry. The bill requires data brokers operating websites or mobile applications to post clear and accessible notices informing consumers that they are engaging in data brokerage. These notices must comply with guidelines set by the Texas Secretary of State and provide consumers with information on how to exercise their rights under Chapter 541 of the Business & Commerce Code.

Additionally, the bill expands the registration requirements for data brokers. They must now include a direct link on their websites with clear instructions for consumers on how to exercise their data privacy rights. Furthermore, data brokers who knowingly collect personal information from minors must disclose their data collection practices, database management, sales activities, and opt-out policies in a detailed statement. These provisions aim to enhance consumer awareness and empower Texans to make informed decisions about their personal data.

Author (1)
Nathan Johnson
Co-Author (1)
Cesar Blanco
Sponsor (1)
Caroline Harris Davila
Fiscal Notes

According to the Legislative Budget Board (LBB), SB 1343 is not expected to have a significant fiscal impact on the state. The bill primarily requires data brokers to provide additional transparency through their websites and registration statements, which does not necessitate substantial state expenditures. Any administrative costs associated with implementing these requirements, such as overseeing compliance or updating guidance for data brokers, can be managed within existing resources.

Similarly, there are no anticipated fiscal implications for local governments. The bill does not impose new regulatory burdens or enforcement responsibilities on local agencies, meaning no additional funding or personnel would be required at the county or municipal level. Overall, SB 1343 is designed to enhance consumer privacy protections without creating significant financial obligations for state or local entities.

Vote Recommendation Notes

SB 1343 strengthens consumer privacy protections by enhancing transparency requirements for data brokers, ensuring that Texans can more easily access and exercise their data rights. This bill builds on prior legislative efforts, particularly SB 2105, which established a data broker registry, and HB 4, also known as the Texas Data Privacy and Security Act (TDPSA). While these laws granted consumers the ability to view, correct, delete, and opt out of the sale of their personal data, their effectiveness has been limited by the difficulty in accessing the necessary information. SB 1343 directly addresses this issue by requiring data brokers to provide clear and prominently displayed links on their websites with specific instructions on how consumers can exercise their rights. This simple but crucial change ensures that the privacy protections already enacted by the Texas Legislature become more meaningful and accessible.

This bill aligns with key liberty-oriented principles. It upholds individual liberty by giving consumers greater control over their personal data and promotes personal responsibility by providing them with the necessary tools to make informed decisions about their digital privacy. Free enterprise remains protected, as the bill does not impose burdensome regulations on businesses but instead encourages greater transparency, allowing market forces to drive accountability. Limited government is maintained since the legislation does not expand regulatory oversight but merely refines existing laws to improve consumer access to information. Private property rights are reinforced, as individuals should have a clear and straightforward way to manage and control their personal information, which is a fundamental aspect of property rights in the digital age.

Both Republican and Democratic platforms support increased consumer data protections, making this bill a rare example of bipartisan agreement on digital privacy issues. The Republican Party of Texas has emphasized the importance of protecting consumer data from intrusive collection practices, while the Texas Democratic Party advocates for enhanced consumer protections in the digital space. The Libertarian Party of Texas also supports policies that reinforce personal privacy and oppose excessive corporate data exploitation. Given this broad ideological support and the bill’s clear benefits to Texans, SB 1343 is a necessary and balanced approach to strengthening consumer rights without imposing excessive regulatory burdens. As such, Texas Policy Research recommends that lawmakers vote YES on SB 1343.

View Bill Text and Status