89th Legislature Regular Session

SB 1864

Overall Vote Recommendation
Yes
Principle Criteria
Free Enterprise
Property Rights
Personal Responsibility
Limited Government
Individual Liberty
Digest

SB 1864 revises Section 132.002 of the Texas Agriculture Code to expand the commercial opportunities for small-scale egg producers by loosening regulatory restrictions on the sale of ungraded eggs. Under current law, individuals selling eggs from their own flocks are generally exempt from the chapter’s requirements so long as they do not claim a grade for the eggs. SB 1864 retains this exemption for direct-to-consumer sales and clarifies that such producers may also sell up to 400 dozen ungraded eggs per week at wholesale to small grocery stores (under 25,000 square feet), restaurants, and cooperative associations.

To ensure transparency and food safety, the bill establishes modest labeling and handling requirements for producers selling at wholesale. Egg cartons must prominently display a label indicating that the eggs are ungraded, along with the producer's name, address, packing date, and license number (if applicable). Wholesale sellers are also required to obtain a license as an “ungraded dealer-wholesaler” from the Texas Department of Agriculture and must adhere to basic sanitation, refrigeration, and recordkeeping protocols to ensure the safe distribution of eggs.

Finally, the bill includes a preemption clause that prohibits any state agency or political subdivision from restricting the purchase, resale, or use of ungraded eggs that comply with these standards. The legislation directs the Texas Department of Agriculture to adopt the necessary administrative rules for implementation.

The House Committee Substitute for SB 1864 makes several substantive and structural changes compared to the Senate Engrossed version, focusing on refining scope, terminology, and administrative requirements for the sale of ungraded eggs in Texas.

One of the key differences is in the weekly wholesale sales limit: the Senate version allows producers to sell up to 500 dozen ungraded eggs per week, while the House substitute reduces this to 400 dozen. Additionally, the House substitute specifies that wholesale sales are limited to particular types of buyers—restaurants, small grocery stores (under 25,000 square feet), and agricultural cooperatives—whereas the Senate version allows wholesale sales more broadly without defining the nature of the buyers.

The licensing requirement also differs in terminology and implementation. The Senate version uses a simpler "registration" requirement with the Texas Department of Agriculture and authorizes a registration fee of up to $50, calling the identifier a "registration number." In contrast, the House substitute replaces this with a more formal "license as an ungraded dealer-wholesaler" and does not reference a specific fee, suggesting potentially stricter oversight or operational standards.

Structurally, the House substitute adds detail to enforcement and compliance by explicitly referencing the relevant statute sections for recordkeeping, refrigeration, and sanitation (Sections 132.061 and 132.045). It also mandates that eggs must be refrigerated within 36 hours of collection and stored at 45°F or lower, which is consistent across both versions but more clearly organized in the House substitute.

Finally, the House substitute includes a preemption clause barring political subdivisions from interfering with the purchase, resale, or use of eligible ungraded eggs—this provision also exists in the Senate version, but its framing in the House substitute is slightly clearer in its scope and protections.

Overall, the House version tightens regulatory boundaries and sharpens clarity on eligible sales channels while preserving the bill's core intent to expand opportunities for small egg producers.

Author
Nathan Johnson
Co-Author
Bryan Hughes
Kevin Sparks
Sponsor
Terry Wilson
Daniel Alders
Briscoe Cain
Brent Money
Philip Cortez
Co-Sponsor
Andy Hopper
Helen Kerwin
Don McLaughlin
Keresa Richardson
Steve Toth
Ellen Troxclair
Cody Vasut
Fiscal Notes

According to the Legislative Budget Board (LBB), the fiscal implications of SB 1864 are currently indeterminate. While the bill authorizes the Texas Department of Agriculture (TDA) to issue licenses for producers who wholesale ungraded eggs, the revenue impact cannot be projected with certainty. This is primarily due to two unknown variables: the specific license fee amount (which the bill authorizes but does not fix) and the number of small-scale producers who would opt into the licensing system to sell up to 400 dozen ungraded eggs per week.

Despite this uncertainty, the LBB indicates that the Texas Department of Agriculture could absorb any administrative costs associated with implementing the bill using existing resources. This suggests that no new appropriations would be immediately required to support enforcement, licensing, or compliance monitoring.

Moreover, the bill could provide a legal basis for future appropriations, depending on how the licensing framework evolves and whether additional resources are later deemed necessary to scale oversight or outreach efforts. At present, however, there are no direct fiscal implications for local governments, as the bill’s provisions do not impose mandates or costs on cities or counties.

Vote Recommendation Notes

SB 1864 advances a meaningful and balanced expansion of commercial opportunities for small-scale egg producers in Texas by legalizing limited wholesale distribution of ungraded eggs. The bill allows producers who do not claim a grade and who operate from their own flocks to sell any quantity directly to consumers and up to 400 dozen eggs per week to certain wholesale buyers—specifically small grocery stores, restaurants, and agricultural cooperatives. This shift enhances economic opportunity and consumer choice while preserving food safety through licensing, labeling, refrigeration, and sanitation requirements.

The bill upholds the principles of individual liberty and free enterprise by reducing unnecessary regulatory barriers that previously prevented small producers from entering wholesale markets without costly grading procedures. It ensures transparency and accountability through clear carton labeling and reasonable oversight via the required license from the Texas Department of Agriculture. Importantly, it also includes a preemption clause that prevents political subdivisions from banning or limiting the purchase and resale of such eggs, supporting a uniform regulatory environment across Texas.

While the fiscal impact is currently indeterminate due to uncertainties around the number of license applicants and the fee amount, the Legislative Budget Board concludes that any administrative costs could be absorbed using existing resources. From a policy perspective, this bill provides a cost-effective way to expand market access, empower small agricultural businesses, and enhance food system resilience without imposing substantial new regulatory burdens.

In sum, SB 1864 exemplifies limited, targeted government action that facilitates greater personal responsibility and economic participation, particularly in rural and local food economies. Texas Policy Research recommends that lawmakers vote YES on SB 1864.

  • Individual Liberty: The bill expands individual freedom by enabling small-scale producers to sell ungraded eggs directly to consumers and to specified wholesale outlets without being subject to the full regulatory framework typically required for graded egg sales. This respects individuals’ rights to engage in voluntary, informed transactions and acknowledges consumers’ capacity to make their own decisions about food purchases when proper labeling is provided.
  • Personal Responsibility: The bill fosters personal responsibility by placing reasonable obligations on producers who choose to sell eggs wholesale. It requires proper labeling, sanitation, refrigeration, and recordkeeping—ensuring that producers are accountable for the safety and traceability of their products. Consumers also assume responsibility in choosing ungraded eggs with full disclosure, supporting a marketplace where decisions are based on trust and transparency rather than overregulation.
  • Free Enterprise: The bill directly advances free enterprise by removing costly and complex regulatory hurdles that have historically blocked small producers from accessing wholesale markets. By creating a licensing pathway for ungraded dealer-wholesalers, the bill unlocks new economic opportunities for small farms and family businesses. It also promotes competition by allowing more sellers into the market, which could improve supply and affordability for buyers like local restaurants and small grocers.
  • Private Property Rights: The bill affirms producers’ rights to the products of their land—their flocks and eggs—by granting them broader latitude to use and sell those products. It recognizes that individuals should be able to commercialize the output of their property (in this case, eggs) within reasonable safety parameters. Additionally, it protects buyers (e.g., small businesses) from being barred by local ordinances from purchasing or reselling these eggs.
  • Limited Government: The bill embodies limited government by reducing unnecessary state interference in small-scale agricultural commerce. It substitutes a burdensome egg grading mandate with a more narrowly tailored licensing and labeling requirement for wholesale sales, coupled with basic food safety rules. It also explicitly preempts local regulations that would otherwise restrict the sale or use of ungraded eggs, ensuring a consistent statewide policy that curtails local overreach.
Related Legislation
View Bill Text and Status