89th Legislature

SB 21

Overall Vote Recommendation
Vote No; Amend
Principle Criteria
Free Enterprise
Property Rights
Personal Responsibility
Limited Government
Individual Liberty
Digest

SB 21, titled the Texas Strategic Bitcoin Reserve and Investment Act, proposes the creation of a Texas Strategic Bitcoin Reserve under the administration of the Texas Comptroller of Public Accounts. The purpose of the reserve is to invest state funds in Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, asserting that these digital assets can serve as a hedge against inflation and economic volatility. The legislation seeks to position Texas as a leader in cryptocurrency adoption while exploring the potential benefits of state-managed digital asset investments.

The bill authorizes the Comptroller to manage the reserve, including buying, holding, selling, and securing cryptocurrency through methods like cold storage. To ensure financial prudence, the bill limits investments to cryptocurrencies that have maintained a market capitalization of at least $500 billion over the previous 12 months. The Comptroller is also allowed to contract with third-party custodians for asset management and security. Additionally, the legislation establishes a Texas Strategic Bitcoin Reserve Advisory Committee, consisting of five members, including cryptocurrency investment experts, to guide investment strategies and risk management.

To maintain transparency, SB 21 requires the Comptroller to publish a biennial report detailing the reserve’s holdings, valuation changes, and administrative actions. The bill also includes provisions for voluntary donations of cryptocurrency to the state, as well as temporary liquidation of reserve funds for cash flow management under specific conditions. The committee substitute may introduce stricter oversight provisions, clarify fund transfer rules, and impose additional risk assessment measures to protect state resources.

Committee Substitute vs. Originally Filed SB 21 – Key Differences

The committee substitute for SB 21 retains the core framework of the originally filed bill, which establishes the Texas Strategic Bitcoin Reserve to allow the Comptroller of Public Accounts to invest in Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies. However, several key modifications were made to clarify oversight, limit risk exposure, and refine the bill’s implementation strategy.

One of the most notable changes is the adjustment in investment oversight. While the originally filed bill granted the Comptroller broad authority to invest in Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, the committee substitute introduces additional safeguards, such as the requirement for an advisory committee to provide guidance on asset valuation and investment policies. Additionally, the committee substitute strengthens reporting requirements, mandating that biennial reports be published publicly and submitted to the Legislature to ensure transparency.

Another key revision involves liquidation and fund management. The original bill allowed the Comptroller to freely liquidate assets and temporarily transfer funds to the state treasury for cash management. In contrast, the committee substitute clarifies the conditions under which liquidation can occur, helping to prevent uncontrolled asset sales during periods of market volatility. Furthermore, the new version prohibits unrestricted fund transfers unless explicitly authorized by the Legislature, ensuring that state funds remain protected from misuse or excessive speculation.

Finally, while both versions limit cryptocurrency investments to assets with a market capitalization of at least $500 billion, the committee substitute emphasizes a prudent investment approach, likely to address concerns about volatility and fiscal responsibility. These refinements reflect an effort to balance innovation with accountability, ensuring that Texas does not overextend itself financially while exploring Bitcoin as a potential state-held asset.

Author
Charles Schwertner
Co-Author
Adam Hinojosa
Tan Parker
Royce West
Sponsor
Giovanni Capriglione
Tom Oliverson
Oscar Longoria
Cody Vasut
Charles Cunningham
Co-Sponsor
Salman Bhojani
Bradley Buckley
Ben Bumgarner
Mano DeAyala
Linda Garcia
Cody Harris
Richard Hayes
Lacey Hull
Carrie Isaac
Stan Kitzman
Marc LaHood
Suleman Lalani
Terri Leo-Wilson
John Lujan
John McQueeney
William Metcalf
Angelia Orr
Jared Patterson
Dennis Paul
Mary Perez
Dade Phelan
Richard Raymond
Keresa Richardson
Steve Toth
Denise Villalobos
Fiscal Notes

The fiscal impact of SB 21 is indeterminate due to uncertainties regarding the amount and value of cryptocurrency that could be deposited into the Texas Strategic Bitcoin Reserve. The bill establishes a special fund outside the state treasury, consisting of legislative appropriations, dedicated revenue, cryptocurrency purchases, investment earnings, and donations. However, because Bitcoin and other digital assets are highly volatile, it is difficult to predict the financial outcomes of the state's investment in these assets.

The Texas Comptroller would be authorized to acquire, manage, and sell Bitcoin and other cryptocurrencies, as well as cover administrative costs using proceeds from the reserve. The bill also allows the reserve's funds to be temporarily transferred to the state treasury for cash management purposes, but these funds must be returned with any accrued interest. Additionally, the bill establishes a Texas Strategic Bitcoin Reserve Advisory Committee to oversee asset valuation and investment policies. While the administrative costs of managing the reserve could be absorbed using proceeds from the fund, the actual financial performance remains unpredictable as it depends on the market value of Bitcoin and other digital assets over time.

A key concern raised in the fiscal note is that moving funds outside the state treasury could limit the Legislature’s future ability to make appropriation decisions regarding these funds. Furthermore, while SB 21 does not include an appropriation, it provides the legal framework for a future appropriation to fund the reserve. The bill also amends Chapter 2256 of the Government Code to clarify that restrictions on state investments would not apply to Bitcoin and cryptocurrency, effectively allowing the state to treat digital assets as an official investment vehicle.

Finally, there is no expected fiscal impact on local governments, as SB 21 primarily affects state-level financial management. However, the risk exposure of state funds to cryptocurrency market fluctuations remains a significant factor that policymakers should consider before implementation.

Vote Recommendation Notes

SB 21 presents a novel approach to integrating cryptocurrency into state investments, positioning Texas as a potential leader in digital asset adoption. However, the bill introduces significant financial risks associated with Bitcoin's volatility, regulatory uncertainty, and lack of historical stability compared to traditional state investments. While the bill attempts to diversify the state's portfolio, it also expands government intervention in private markets and could expose taxpayer funds to unpredictable fluctuations. Therefore, amendments are recommended to limit exposure, clarify risk management strategies, and ensure legislative oversight.

While the committee substitute for SB 21 improves oversight, transparency, and investment controls, it does not fully address key concerns related to financial risk, government overreach, and taxpayer exposure. The changes in the substitute version make the bill more structured, but fundamental risks still exist, which is why the recommended amendments remain crucial.

While SB 21 aligns with innovation and financial modernization, it conflicts with limited government and free-market principles. If Texas wants to encourage Bitcoin adoption, it should focus on removing regulatory barriers for private businesses rather than investing taxpayer funds in speculative assets. Amendments should include:

  • Limit State Exposure to Cryptocurrency Volatility: Cap the percentage of state funds that can be allocated to the Texas Strategic Bitcoin Reserve. This would prevent overexposure of state resources to highly volatile digital assets and ensure that traditional investments (e.g. gold, bonds, and real estate) remain the foundation of Texas' financial resilience.
  • Strengthen Oversight & Transparency: Require quarterly public audits instead of biennial reports. Given cryptocurrency's volatility, a biennial report is insufficient. This would ensure continuous legislative oversight to prevent financial mismanagement.
  • Restrict the Comptroller’s Investment Authority: Prevent risky trading practices and require passive holding only. This would prevent high-risk trading strategies that could lead to massive state losses and encourage conservative, long-term asset management in line with traditional treasury practices.
  • Require a Clear Exit Strategy: Define pre-set conditions for liquidating Bitcoin holdings to minimize taxpayer losses. This would avoid holding Bitcoin or other cryptocurrency at a loss indefinitely and prevent Texas taxpayers from absorbing major losses due to market crashes.
  • Prohibit Use of State Pension Funds or Essential Services Funds: Prevent any retirement, education, or public service funds from being used for Bitcoin investments. This would protect retirement and essential services from potential high-risk losses and ensure only discretionary state funds are used in Bitcoin investments.
  • Establish Clear Rules for Accepting Cryptocurrency Donations:  Require vetting and approval processes for Bitcoin donations to prevent money laundering. This would prevent Texas from becoming a laundering hub for illicit Bitcoin and ensure donations align with federal financial regulations.

Without these amendments, SB 21 poses significant risks to Texas taxpayers, financial stability, and free-market principles. If Texas wants to be a leader in Bitcoin adoption, it should focus on deregulating cryptocurrency commerce, not managing speculative state investments.

SB 21 is a named legislative priority of Texas Lt. Gov. Dan Patrick.

View Bill Text and Status