SB 565

Overall Vote Recommendation
Vote No; Amend
Principle Criteria
neutral
Free Enterprise
negative
Property Rights
negative
Personal Responsibility
positive
Limited Government
negative
Individual Liberty
Digest
SB 565 proposes amendments to Sections 7.0026(b) and (c) of the Texas Water Code. It allows the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) to enter compliance agreements with regional water supply, sewer, wastewater treatment, or solid waste disposal services. These agreements suspend enforcement actions against a regional service entity integrating a service area with pre-existing violations. The agreements must outline steps to bring the integrated service into compliance.
Author (1)
Charles Perry
Co-Author (1)
Cesar Blanco
Sponsor (1)
Caroline Harris Davila
Fiscal Notes

The Legislative Budget Board's fiscal note for SB 565 indicates that the bill is not expected to have a significant financial impact on the state. Any administrative costs associated with implementing compliance agreements would likely be absorbed using existing resources within the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ). This suggests that the bill does not create new financial burdens requiring additional state funding.

Similarly, no significant fiscal impact is anticipated for local governments. The bill provides flexibility to regional water supply, sewer, wastewater treatment, and solid waste disposal services by temporarily suspending enforcement actions during service integration. This could potentially reduce immediate compliance costs for these entities, but it does not impose new financial obligations on local governments.

Overall, SB 565 appears to be fiscally neutral, ensuring that regulatory flexibility is provided without necessitating additional appropriations or creating cost burdens for state or local agencies​.

Vote Recommendation Notes

SB 565 seeks to facilitate the consolidation of small, often struggling water and wastewater systems into larger regional utilities by allowing the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality (TCEQ) to enter into compliance agreements that temporarily suspend enforcement actions on existing or anticipated violations. This policy builds upon HB 3232, passed in the 88th Legislature, which first introduced these safe harbor provisions. The bill clarifies that all types of retail public utilities—not just those traditionally recognized as “regional services”—are eligible for these compliance agreements.

The bill has merit in addressing a real problem: many small rural water systems are financially unable to meet state and federal water quality standards. Consolidation into larger systems is often the most practical and cost-effective solution, as it allows repair and compliance costs to be distributed across a larger customer base. However, the temporary suspension of enforcement raises concerns about accountability and potential health risks. Without clear compliance deadlines or mandated progress benchmarks, there is a risk that some systems could delay necessary improvements while operating under a compliance agreement.

While SB 565 supports a necessary policy goal, an amendment should be added to require stricter timelines and progress benchmarks for compliance agreements to prevent indefinite delays in addressing water quality violations. This would strike a better balance between regulatory flexibility and public health protection.

Related Legislation
View Bill Text and Status