Estimated Time to Read: 9 minutes
The Texas court system is large, layered, and uniquely structured. Texans often encounter it through criminal cases, civil disputes, family matters, and appeals. Its complexity is rooted in Texas history, constitutional design, and the state’s commitment to local control. Understanding how the Texas judiciary works starts with its different levels of courts, the jurisdiction they hold, and the way Texans choose their judges.
The Structure of the Texas Judiciary
Texas maintains a multi-tiered court hierarchy that stretches from municipal and justice courts at the local level to the Supreme Court of Texas and the Texas Court of Criminal Appeals at the top. Texas is also the only state in the country with two high courts of last resort. The Supreme Court handles civil matters and juvenile civil cases, while the Court of Criminal Appeals hears criminal appeals. Together, they form the highest judicial authorities in the state.
Local Trial Courts in Texas
Local courts are the entry point for many Texans interacting with the legal system. They include Municipal Courts and Justice of the Peace Courts. These trial courts handle the volume of day-to-day issues that arise in communities and often provide the first judicial ruling in a case.
Municipal Courts in Texas
Municipal Courts operate within city limits and hear low-level offenses created by local ordinances. Their jurisdiction includes Class C misdemeanors, traffic tickets, city code violations, and minor criminal matters. Municipal judges may be appointed or elected, depending on the city charter. These courts do not conduct jury trials in every instance but must offer the option when state law requires it.
Justice of the Peace Courts and Their Role
Justice of the Peace Courts function at the county level and also handle Class C misdemeanors, along with civil disputes involving limited monetary amounts. They preside over cases such as small claims, evictions, truancy, and debt claims. Many county residents know them for performing weddings or handling inquests, but they remain an official part of the Texas judicial system with binding authority. Justices of the Peace are elected in partisan elections.
County Level Trial Courts in Texas
County courts serve as the next layer in the Texas court system and often handle cases that move beyond the limited jurisdiction of local courts. This tier includes Constitutional County Courts, County Courts at Law, and Statutory Probate Courts.
Constitutional County Courts and Their Jurisdiction
Each county in Texas has a single Constitutional County Court. These courts oversee misdemeanors that carry possible jail time, certain civil cases, appeals from Municipal Courts and Justice Courts, and administrative matters involving commissioners’ courts. The constitutional county judge is elected in a partisan election and also carries executive responsibilities, which sets Texas apart from many other states.
County Courts at Law and Expanded Authority
County Courts at Law are statutory courts created by the Legislature to relieve crowded county dockets. Their jurisdiction varies by county but commonly includes higher-level misdemeanors, civil cases involving larger monetary amounts, and appellate jurisdiction from local courts. Judges are elected in partisan elections and must meet statutory qualifications that exceed those of constitutional county judges.
Statutory Probate Courts and Their Specialty
Statutory Probate Courts exist in large urban counties and focus exclusively on probate matters, guardianship cases, and mental health proceedings. They manage estate administration and disputes involving wills, trusts, and incapacitated individuals. Judges are elected in partisan elections and must meet advanced legal qualifications that reflect the specialized nature of the docket.
District Courts in Texas
District Courts serve as the primary trial courts of general jurisdiction in Texas. They hear felony criminal cases, divorce proceedings, child custody cases, civil disputes without monetary limits, and major lawsuits involving property, contracts, and tort claims. These courts also hear appeals from county courts when authorized by statute. District Court judges are elected in partisan elections and must be licensed attorneys with substantial legal experience.
District Courts sit at the center of the Texas court system because they oversee the widest variety of high-stakes cases. Their rulings often set the stage for the legal reasoning that higher courts may later review.
The Texas Courts of Appeals
Fourteen intermediate appellate courts serve the state of Texas, and review cases appealed from District Courts and many county-level courts. These Courts of Appeals do not typically review new evidence. Instead, they examine the trial record to determine whether legal errors occurred. Panels of three justices review each appeal, although courts may hear cases en banc in certain situations. Justices on the Courts of Appeals are elected in partisan elections within their respective regions and must meet the same professional requirements as District Court judges.
These appellate courts play an essential role in shaping Texas law because they issue hundreds of opinions each year that interpret statutes, define standards of review, and guide lower courts.
The Court of Criminal Appeals
The Court of Criminal Appeals (CCA) is Texas’s highest court for criminal matters and serves as the court of last resort for criminal cases in the state. It reviews appeals in criminal proceedings, including cases involving capital punishment, and its decisions establish binding precedent for every criminal court in Texas.
In addition to its role reviewing direct criminal appeals, the CCA serves as the final authority for post-conviction habeas corpus proceedings under Article 11.07 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure. These habeas applications allow individuals convicted of felonies to challenge their convictions or sentences after the direct appeal process has concluded. Post-conviction habeas review represents a substantial portion of the court’s docket and is a central mechanism through which the court evaluates constitutional claims, ineffective assistance of counsel allegations, and other collateral challenges within the Texas criminal justice system.
The court exercises discretionary review over most petitions, meaning it chooses which cases to hear, but it must accept direct appeals in death penalty cases. This structure gives the Court of Criminal Appeals significant influence over how criminal law is interpreted and applied statewide. Judges on the court are elected statewide in partisan elections, reinforcing the court’s unique role at the intersection of criminal justice, constitutional interpretation, and democratic accountability in Texas.
Editor’s note: This section was updated to explicitly note the Court of Criminal Appeals’ role in post-conviction habeas corpus proceedings under Article 11.07 of the Texas Code of Criminal Procedure, which constitute a significant portion of the court’s docket.
The Supreme Court of Texas
The Supreme Court of Texas serves as the state’s highest court for civil matters. It hears civil appeals, juvenile civil cases, and certain administrative actions involving state agencies. Like the Court of Criminal Appeals, it exercises discretionary review over most cases, selecting those that present significant legal questions or require clarification of Texas law.
The court also oversees the licensing of attorneys, judicial conduct, and procedural rules for all Texas courts. The nine justices are elected statewide in partisan elections, though discussions about reforming the judicial selection process surface frequently in the Legislature.
How Texas Judges Are Elected
Judicial selection in Texas is a politically charged subject because Texas is one of the few states where all judges are chosen through partisan elections. This includes judges in Municipal Courts when city ordinances require elections. Most judges campaign on political party lines and appear on primary and general election ballots. Terms vary depending on the court. Local judges typically serve four-year terms, while appellate judges serve six-year terms.
Partisan elections give voters the power to select judges, but critics argue that the system subjects the judiciary to political pressure. Debates over moving to nonpartisan elections or merit selection appear during legislative sessions, yet the partisan model continues to be the statewide standard.
The Appellate Process in the Texas Court System
The appellate process begins when a party believes a legal error occurred at the trial level. Most appeals move first to the Courts of Appeals. These courts review the written record, consider legal arguments, and issue written opinions. If a party seeks further review, the case may be appealed to the Supreme Court of Texas or the Court of Criminal Appeals.
These high courts select only a small number of cases each year. Their decisions shape Texas law for generations and often influence legislative reforms. Appeals may involve constitutional interpretation, statutory construction, or procedural issues that impact every trial court in the state.
Specialized Courts in the Texas Judiciary
Texas also maintains specialized courts created by statute or constitution to address specific legal needs. These include Veterans Treatment Courts, Drug Courts, Child Protection Courts, and Business Courts.
Veterans Treatment Courts and Rehabilitation
Veterans Treatment Courts assist veterans charged with certain offenses by providing treatment, counseling, and support. They operate on the premise that addressing underlying issues such as Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) or substance abuse is essential to reducing recidivism and improving outcomes for veterans.
Drug Courts and Restorative Justice
Drug Courts focus on rehabilitation rather than incarceration. They operate as problem-solving courts that structure treatment, testing, and accountability measures to reduce drug-related offenses. These courts have become an important part of Texas’s effort to move nonviolent offenders toward rehabilitation.
Child Protection Courts and Family Welfare
Child Protection Courts oversee cases involving foster care, child abuse, and neglect. Their role is to ensure timely hearings and decisions in matters involving vulnerable Texas children.
Business Courts and Economic Litigation
The Texas Business Courts, created by the Legislature, handle complex business disputes involving large dollar amounts or multi-state corporations. These courts seek to provide efficiency and clarity for commercial litigation. Judges are appointed by the Governor and confirmed by the Senate, which distinguishes them from most Texas courts.
The Importance of Understanding the Texas Judicial System
The Texas judicial system influences nearly every part of public life, from criminal justice and family law to business regulation and constitutional rights. With courts spread across different jurisdictions and judges chosen through partisan elections, the system reflects the state’s emphasis on local control and democratic accountability.
Understanding how the Texas court system works provides insight into how laws are interpreted, how disputes are resolved, and how the rule of law is maintained across the state. Texans who understand their courts are better equipped to navigate legal challenges, engage in public policy debates, and evaluate candidates during judicial elections.
Texas Courts and the Rule of Law
The Texas court system is a complex but vital institution. Its structure provides local access to justice, statewide consistency through appellate review, and dual oversight from two high courts that separate civil and criminal authority. Judges serve at the intersection of law and democracy, and Texans play a direct role in shaping the judiciary through elections.
By understanding each tier of the Texas judicial system, Texans can better appreciate how cases move through the courts, how judges carry out their responsibilities, and how the judiciary upholds justice throughout the state.
Texas Policy Research relies on the support of generous donors across Texas.
If you found this information helpful, please consider supporting our efforts! Thank you!
