SB 509

Overall Vote Recommendation
Vote Yes; Amend
Principle Criteria
neutral
Free Enterprise
neutral
Property Rights
neutral
Personal Responsibility
neutral
Limited Government
neutral
Individual Liberty
Digest
SB 509 amends Subchapter E, Chapter 273 of the Texas Election Code to require that courts provide notice to the Texas Attorney General (AG) before holding a hearing on any temporary restraining order (TRO) sought under the Election Code. The bill adds Section 273.082, which mandates that notification be given as soon as practicable before the hearing, though it does not specify a deadline or enforcement mechanism for failure to notify the AG.

This legislation is intended to ensure the AG is aware of legal actions affecting election procedures and may intervene or respond accordingly. The bill does not alter the criteria for obtaining a TRO but introduces a procedural step that could affect the speed of emergency election-related rulings.
Author (5)
Paul Bettencourt
Mayes Middleton
Tan Parker
Angela Paxton
Charles Perry
Co-Author (1)
Bob Hall
Sponsor (1)
Michael Schofield
Fiscal Notes

According to the Legislative Budget Board (LBB), SB 509 is not expected to have a significant fiscal impact on the state. The bill requires courts to notify the Texas Attorney General (AG) before holding a hearing on a temporary restraining order (TRO) under the Election Code. The LBB assumes that any administrative costs related to this requirement can be absorbed within existing resources at the Office of Court Administration and the Attorney General’s Office.

Additionally, local governments are not expected to incur significant costs due to this legislation. Since the bill does not mandate additional hearings or legal proceedings, but rather a notification requirement, no major operational expenses are anticipated at the county or municipal level. The Office of Court Administration and the Attorney General’s Office have been identified as the primary state agencies affected, but they are expected to handle the implementation within their current budgets.

Vote Recommendation Notes

SB 509 proposes a procedural change in election-related litigation by requiring courts to notify the Texas Attorney General (AG) before holding a hearing on temporary restraining orders (TROs) sought under the Election Code. This measure stems from a 2022 Harris County case, where a court extended polling hours via a TRO without notifying the AG, even though the election involved state and federal offices.

The bill does not impose direct restrictions on election litigation but adds a procedural step that could delay urgent legal relief in election-related disputes. While ensuring the AG’s awareness of election-related legal proceedings could promote consistency and oversight, it also risks interfering with judicial discretion and slowing emergency rulings. The lack of a strict deadline or enforcement mechanism raises concerns about potential delays in time-sensitive cases.

Given these implications, though Texas Policy Research recommends lawmakers vote YES on SB 509, the bill should be amended to clarify how courts should notify the AG and define an explicit timeframe for notification. These adjustments would balance election integrity, judicial efficiency, and government oversight, making the bill more functional without unduly delaying election-related legal remedies.

Related Legislation
View Bill Text and Status