The fiscal note for Senate Bill 988 outlines several potential financial impacts tied to the bill’s enhancement of criminal penalties for damaging motor fuel pumps. However, it emphasizes that the precise fiscal implications cannot be determined due to a lack of statewide data specifically identifying how frequently such acts occur. This uncertainty affects the ability to forecast costs to the state in terms of increased prosecutions or incarcerations.

By elevating the offense from a misdemeanor to a third-degree felony, the bill could result in more individuals being sentenced to prison or placed under felony-level community supervision. For reference, the daily cost of supervising an adult on felony probation in Texas in fiscal year 2024 was $2.73, while incarcerating an adult in a systemwide facility costs $86.50 per day. This increase in punishment level could also affect the juvenile justice system, potentially leading to more juveniles committed to state-run facilities, which have a much higher daily cost—$770.53 per juvenile per day in 2024.

Although the Office of Court Administration anticipates no significant impact on the court system, the Comptroller’s office noted there could be some increase in state revenue from court costs. Local government fiscal impacts are likewise indeterminate and would depend on the balance between individuals placed under community supervision versus those sent to state correctional institutions.

In short, while SB 988 has the potential to raise state correctional costs and possibly court-related revenue, the full fiscal impact remains undetermined due to data limitations.

SB 988 proposes a targeted amendment to the Texas Penal Code aimed at deterring a specific form of organized fuel theft by reclassifying damage to motor fuel pumps as a third-degree felony. The author's statement of intent outlines how criminal groups have exploited vulnerabilities in gas station technology—particularly the fuel pulser—to steal large volumes of fuel. Law enforcement, limited by current misdemeanor-level penalties, are often unable to impose consequences that reflect the organized and systemic nature of the crime. SB 988 seeks to elevate the seriousness of this act in statute, giving prosecutors and police stronger leverage in responding to this issue.

From a liberty principle standpoint, the bill supports private property rights and free enterprise by helping protect gas stations and fuel infrastructure from costly vandalism and theft. It also promotes personal responsibility by raising consequences for deliberate damage. However, concerns arise under the principle of limited government. Reclassifying relatively low-dollar property damage as a felony may unintentionally expand the scope of state penal authority, particularly in cases where the act is not tied to an organized operation. This raises concerns about proportionality in sentencing and the broader social and financial costs associated with felony convictions, including incarceration.

Moreover, the fiscal analysis reveals indeterminate but potentially significant impacts on state correctional resources and juvenile justice systems, since increasing the penalty could result in more individuals being imprisoned or placed under higher-cost supervision. While the bill is likely to reduce fuel theft over time, its long-term effects on the justice system and correctional budgets require closer scrutiny.

In summary, SB 988 is a reasonable response to a pressing public safety and property rights issue but would benefit from amendments to clarify intent, incorporate proportionality thresholds, or introduce alternative penalties such as restitution or tiered sentencing. This would strike a better balance between deterrence and limiting unnecessary expansion of government enforcement power. As such, though Texas Policy Research recommends that lawmakers vote YES on SB 988, we also strongly urge lawmakers to consider the aforementioned amendments.

• HB 2461 (Similar To)