Overall Vote Recommendation

Yes

Principle Criteria

Free Enterprise

Property Rights

Personal Responsibility

Limited Government

Individual Liberty

Digest

HB 4337 amends provisions of the Transportation Code governing branch pilots serving the ports of Harris County. The bill expands and clarifies the jurisdiction of the Board of Pilot Commissioners by expressly providing that its authority extends to pilot services at intermediate stops, anchorages, and landing places associated with vessels using the Houston Ship Channel. It also broadens the statutory definition of a "Harris County port" to include qualifying locations in both Harris and Chambers counties, as well as the waterways connecting those locations to the Gulf of Mexico.

The bill also modifies the licensing framework for deputy branch pilots. Under current law, a deputy branch pilot certificate expires after three years and is not renewable. The Committee Substitute extends the certificate term to four years and authorizes renewal, provided the deputy branch pilot is reappointed by a branch pilot in accordance with existing law. In doing so, the bill removes the current prohibition that prevents an individual from receiving another deputy branch pilot certificate within five years of the original issuance. These changes allow qualified deputy branch pilots to continue serving without repeating the initial certification process, so long as they remain reappointed.

Compared with the originally filed version, the Committee Substitute expands the jurisdictional provisions by expressly including intermediate stops, anchorages, and landing places within the Board of Pilot Commissioners' authority and revises the definition of Harris County ports to encompass additional locations in Chambers County connected by the Houston Ship Channel. It also replaces the existing prohibition on renewing deputy branch pilot certificates with a renewable four-year certification process tied to continued appointment by a branch pilot.

The Committee Substitute for HB 4337 retains the original bill's primary objective of expanding the definition of a Harris County port to include qualifying locations in Chambers County and modernizing the certification process for deputy branch pilots. Both versions extend the validity of a deputy branch pilot certificate from three years to four years, authorize certificate renewal following reappointment by a branch pilot, and remove the existing five-year waiting period before a former deputy branch pilot may receive another certificate.

The Committee Substitute makes two significant policy changes from the originally filed bill. First, instead of amending the conflict-of-interest provisions governing members of the Board of Pilot Commissioners, the substitute removes that proposal entirely. The originally filed bill would have broadened the prohibition on board members holding business interests that could adversely affect their duties by replacing narrower statutory language with a more general conflict-of-interest standard. That provision does not appear in the committee substitute.

In place of the removed ethics provision, the Committee Substitute adds a new jurisdictional clarification for the Board of Pilot Commissioners. The substitute expressly provides that the board has exclusive jurisdiction over pilots providing services not only at Harris County ports, but also at intermediate stops, anchorages, and landing places within the board's jurisdiction. It also expands the definition of a Harris County port by specifying that the waterway leading from the Gulf of Mexico includes intermediate stops, anchorages, and landing places. These additions clarify the board's regulatory authority over vessel movements along the Houston Ship Channel and related waterways, rather than focusing on board member qualifications as proposed in the originally filed version.

Author (4)

Mary Perez

Terry Canales

Jared Patterson

Ana Hernandez

Contact the Author

Rep. Mary Perez

Capitol Phone:

(512) 463-0460

Capitol Office:

CAP 1N.7

E-Mail:

[email protected]

Visit Official Website

Fiscal Notes

According to the Legislative Budget Board (LBB), HB 4337 is not expected to have a fiscal impact on the state government. The LBB concluded that implementing the bill's provisions relating to the regulation of pilots for the ports of Harris County can be accomplished using existing state resources and does not require additional appropriations or generate state savings.

The LBB also determined that the bill would not have a significant fiscal impact on units of local government. Although the bill modifies the jurisdiction of the Board of Pilot Commissioners for Harris County ports and revises the certification and renewal process for deputy branch pilots, these changes are not expected to impose meaningful costs or savings on local governmental entities.

Vote Recommendation Notes

HB 4337 makes limited, targeted changes to the regulation of pilot services serving the Houston Ship Channel without materially expanding the size or scope of state government. Rather than creating a new regulatory program or granting broad new authority, the bill clarifies the existing jurisdiction of the Board of Pilot Commissioners to include intermediate stops, anchorages, and landing places associated with vessels using the Houston Ship Channel. According to the committee analysis, these changes are intended to ensure consistent pilotage services for future maritime facilities in Chambers County, including the proposed Cedar Port terminal, while maintaining a single regulatory framework for vessels operating on the same waterway.

The bill also modernizes the deputy branch pilot certification process by extending the certificate term from three to four years and authorizing renewals for deputy pilots who remain reappointed during training. These revisions address administrative inefficiencies identified by stakeholders, allowing trainees additional time to complete the existing training program when unforeseen circumstances arise without requiring them to restart the certification process. The bill does not reduce training standards or expand eligibility for licensure; it simply provides greater administrative flexibility within the current regulatory structure.

From a limited-government perspective, the bill does not meaningfully increase the burden on taxpayers, expand bureaucracy, or impose new regulatory requirements on businesses or individuals. The LBB determined that implementation will have no fiscal implication for the state government and no significant fiscal implication for local governments, indicating that the bill can be administered using existing resources. Likewise, the committee analysis confirms that the bill creates no new criminal offenses, grants no additional rulemaking authority, and primarily clarifies existing law rather than establishing new regulatory mandates. While the bill modestly expands the geographic application of the existing pilotage system to accommodate anticipated port development, it does so within the current regulatory framework and without creating significant new governmental authority or taxpayer obligations. Accordingly, the bill represents a narrowly tailored administrative update that supports efficient maritime commerce while maintaining limited fiscal and regulatory impacts.

As such, Texas Policy Research recommends that lawmakers vote YES on HB 4337.

Individual Liberty: The bill does not create new mandates, prohibitions, criminal offenses, or enforcement mechanisms affecting individual rights. It primarily updates administrative provisions governing state-regulated maritime pilots and clarifies existing jurisdiction.
Personal Responsibility: The bill reinforces a professional licensing system that emphasizes continued qualification and reappointment rather than restarting the certification process after administrative delays. Renewing a deputy branch pilot certificate remains contingent on continued appointment by a branch pilot, preserving individual accountability while reducing unnecessary procedural barriers.
Free Enterprise: By clarifying pilotage jurisdiction for future port development in Chambers County and ensuring continuity of pilot services along the Houston Ship Channel, the bill supports maritime commerce and reduces regulatory uncertainty for future port operations. It does not impose new regulatory burdens on businesses beyond the existing pilotage framework.
Private Property Rights: The bill does not affect ownership, use, regulation, or takings of private property. Its provisions are limited to the regulation of maritime pilot services and professional certification.
Limited Government: Although the bill modestly expands the Board of Pilot Commissioners' expressly stated jurisdiction to include anchorages and intermediate stops associated with the Houston Ship Channel, it does not establish a new agency, create new programs, grant additional rulemaking authority, or increase state spending. The Legislative Budget Board found no fiscal impact to the state or significant impact to local governments, suggesting the bill clarifies and administers existing authority rather than materially expanding government.

View Bill Text and Status