Katherine McLane – Texas: Bring Bipartisanship Back

Estimated Time to Read: 6 minutes

Editor's Note: The following guest commentary reflects the views and opinions of the author alone and does not necessarily represent the official views of Texas Policy Research, its staff, board, or affiliated organizations. Guest submissions are lightly edited for grammar, formatting, clarity, and length while preserving the author's voice and arguments.

In the late 1990s, Republican Gov. George W. Bush and Democratic Lt. Gov. Bob Bullock had what was affectionately known in Texas as the “Bush-Bullock love fest.” Bullock mentored the new governor, showed him the ropes, and helped shape his leadership. Their relationship set a tone of cooperation in the Legislature and embodied a bipartisanship that was once fairly common in this state. Man, you don’t know what you’ve got 'till it’s gone.

When I began my career at Public Strategies, Inc. in Austin in 2001, I was honored to walk the halls with legends like former Democratic Gov. Ann Richards and Republicans like Mark McKinnon, George W. Bush’s chief campaign media guru. People who disagreed profoundly about policy till managed to agree as colleagues. They traded war stories, broke bread, and worked together when the moment called for it.

While serving in Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger’s administration, I heard him endlessly champion “post-partisanship,” the idea of putting people’s needs ahead of party loyalty. And at the conclusion of my time in public service, I was proud to watch leaders model a warm, gracious handoff of power, the kind of transition that reassures a country that its institutions are bigger than any one faction.

That spirit of bipartisanship and grace gave way to vitriol over the past decade, especially within the Texas GOP. Republicans questioned their peers’ loyalty and invented policy litmus tests. Fail one, and you were branded a RINO, a “Republican in Name Only.” Principled Republican incumbents in the Texas Legislature who voted their conscience faced primary challenges orchestrated by leaders of their own party whom they had supported for years. Democrats, meanwhile, were pushed out of committee chairmanships despite representing millions of Texans. Where were the people in all of this? Lost in the shuffle.

But Texans sent a clear signal in this election. They want civility and decorum back. They want people’s needs to come first, not party interests. After years of scorched-earth politics, voters appear ready for something steadier.

And here is another layer worth noticing. For the first time in Texas history, women are poised to hold all three of the state’s most powerful offices: governor, lieutenant governor, and speaker of the House. Perhaps most remarkable is presumptive Speaker Senfronia Thompson, an 87-year-old veteran Democrat affectionately known around the Capitol as Ms. T, who has served in the Texas House since 1973. Whatever one thinks of her politics, a career of that length is a testament to persistence and institutional knowledge that any legislator, of either party, would do well to respect.

I will be among countless Texans downright angry if Ms. T is not treated with respect, along with the other women voters have elected to lead our state. Disagree on policy, by all means. That is what the arena is for. But no more personal attacks or demonization. No sly digs at leaders who happen to be female. Let’s all be gentlemen again, please.

None of this is a call to paper over real disagreement. Texas faces hard choices on property taxes, the power grid, water, public education, and the pace of growth, and those challenges should rightly receive due debate. Bipartisanship does not mean splitting every difference or pretending the parties want the same things. It means remembering that the person across the aisle, or across a primary, is a fellow Texan and not an enemy, and that the work of governing continues long after the campaign ends. The tone leaders set shapes whether capable people still want to serve at all.

Our next generation of leaders would be wise to abandon the playbook that cost Republicans the midterms and embrace bipartisanship again. Reach across the aisle. Debate vigorously, but treat one another, and all Texans, with respect. Govern as though the people watching are the point, because they are.

Let’s bring back the Bush-Bullock spirit. It is what Texans deserve, and, judging by this last election, it is what they are demanding.

Katherine McLane

About the Author: Katherine McLane is the founder and CEO of The Mach 1 Group, a Texas-based strategic communications firm. A graduate of Texas A&M University, she began her career at Public Strategies, Inc. in Austin and went on to serve in Gov. Arnold Schwarzenegger's administration and to lead crisis communications for the LIVESTRONG Foundation. She is a former chair of the Ann Richards School Foundation Board of Directors and writes from decades of experience in Texas and national politics and communications.

Disclosure: The author is the founder and CEO of The Mach 1 Group, a strategic communications firm she describes as nonpartisan, and she notes an interest in promoting the firm's nonpartisan positioning. She reports no financial interest in the subject of this commentary and is not a registered lobbyist. Guest contributors write independently of our positions; we neither require agreement nor decline submissions on the basis of disagreement.


Support Our Work

Texas Policy Research relies on generous donors across Texas. If you found this helpful, please consider supporting our efforts.

Donate Today

Stay in the Loop

Subscribe for occasional emails with new research, event details, and ways to engage with Texas policy.

Subscribe for Updates