Estimated Time to Read: 11 minutes
When the Bastrop City Council spent two days in August discussing the city's budget, tax rate, water infrastructure, data center development, and Flock Safety surveillance cameras, it did so in Fredericksburg, more than 100 miles from Bastrop. One resident attended in person.
That retreat is now the catalyst for two bills filed ahead of the 90th Legislative Session that would limit where the governing bodies of cities, counties, school districts, and other political subdivisions may meet. House Bill 913 (HB 913), filed by State Rep. Stan Gerdes (R-Smithville), whose House District 17 includes Bastrop, would require meetings to take place inside a political subdivision's boundaries. House Bill 694 (HB 694), filed by State Rep. Cody Vasut (R-Angleton), would allow meetings up to 10 miles outside those boundaries and adds an exception for countywide evacuations.
Vasut currently chairs the House Select Committee on Governmental Oversight, which examined the issue at an interim hearing on August 26, 2026. Both bills also track concerns Texas Policy Research (TPR) raised in its previous coverage of the retreat and in testimony before that committee: whether the Texas Open Meetings Act (TOMA) protects the public's practical ability to observe local government deliberations, not merely their technical availability.
Bastrop Retreat Sparks Open Meetings Act Debate
The council's two-day workshop, which began August 6 in Fredericksburg, was publicly posted and livestreamed. Its location nonetheless raised questions about whether residents could realistically attend. As TPR previously reported, the council discussed the city's budget, tax rate, transportation priorities, water infrastructure, data center development, and the use of Flock Safety surveillance cameras. These were not administrative or ceremonial matters; they carried real consequences for Bastrop taxpayers, property owners, and residents.
At the August 26 hearing, Bastrop officials acknowledged that only one resident attended in person. Mayor Ishmael Harris defended the meeting, emphasizing that it had been properly noticed, was open to the public, and was livestreamed, and arguing that council members benefited from working away from their ordinary surroundings.
Lawmakers on the committee did not argue that the city had broken the law. Their questions focused instead on whether technical compliance was enough when the meeting was held where almost no residents could attend.
The exchange captures the difference between making government proceedings technically available and giving residents a reasonable opportunity to attend them. The TOMA generally requires governmental bodies to give public notice and deliberate openly, subject to statutory exceptions, but it sets no location requirement that applies across political subdivisions. Some entity-specific statutes address where particular bodies meet. Section 81.005 of the Local Government Code, for example, generally requires a county commissioners court to meet at the county seat, with limited exceptions. No general rule, however, covers local governments as a whole. Both bills seek to fill that gap.
HB 913 Would Require Meetings Within Boundaries
HB 913 would add Section 551.008 to the Government Code, requiring the governmental body of a political subdivision to hold its meetings at a designated location inside that subdivision's boundaries. A city council would meet within city limits; a commissioners court would meet within the county. Telephone and video conference meetings would remain available under existing law, but the physical location those meetings require would have to satisfy the same boundary rule.
The bill contains no exception for natural disasters, evacuations, unavailable facilities, or other extraordinary circumstances, making it the stricter of the two proposals. Its main advantage is simplicity: local governments would have a bright-line rule, leaving little room for dispute over whether an off-site meeting is allowed.
That simplicity has costs. A political subdivision might need to relocate temporarily because of severe weather or damage to its facilities, and HB 913 does not expressly accommodate that. Smaller entities that rely on meeting space outside their boundaries could also be affected. The bill would stop a retreat 100 miles away, but it would equally prohibit an accessible meeting at a facility just outside the city limits. Geographic boundaries do not always match practical accessibility.
HB 694 Adds a 10-Mile Buffer and Evacuation Exception
HB 694 would add a section of the same number but take a more flexible approach, permitting meetings at a designated location either inside the political subdivision's boundaries or within 10 miles of them. That allowance could accommodate local governments that share facilities, lack adequate space, or sit near a boundary where the nearest suitable facility lies just outside their territory. It also mirrors the approach Vasut floated at the August hearing: a general requirement that political subdivisions meet within or near their boundaries. Like HB 913, the bill preserves telephone and video conference meetings and applies the location rule to their physical sites.
HB 694 also includes an evacuation exception. If an evacuation order covers the entire county in which a political subdivision is located, its governing body may meet in the closest county not also under a mandatory evacuation order. The exception is narrow, however. It does not address localized disasters, damaged facilities, or evacuation orders covering only part of a county. The 10-mile allowance could also still permit meetings that are hard for residents to reach, depending on transportation networks, population distribution, and where the facility sits. HB 694 offers more operational flexibility, but it does not fully resolve the tension between a geographic rule and meaningful access.
HB 913 vs. HB 694: Comparing the Proposals
Both bills address the same transparency concern, and their differences could become consequential as lawmakers weigh public access against local government operations.
| Provision | HB 913Rep. Stan Gerdes (R-Smithville) | HB 694Rep. Cody Vasut (R-Angleton) |
|---|---|---|
| Permitted meeting location | Inside boundaries only | Inside boundaries or within 10 miles of them |
| Telephone/video meetings | Permitted under existing law; physical location must meet the boundary rule | Same |
| Countywide evacuation exception | None | Yes: may meet in the closest county not under a mandatory evacuation order |
| Other emergency exceptions | None | None |
| Effective date | Sept. 1, 2027 | Sept. 1, 2027 |
The bills are separate proposals, not companion legislation. Because both would add a new Section 551.008 to the Government Code, lawmakers would need to reconcile them if both advanced. Neither bill requires livestreaming, creates a new public comment requirement, or prohibits retreats and workshops outright. Both focus solely on where meetings subject to the Act may physically occur.
How the Bills Measure Up to TPR's Recommendations
In written testimony to the select committee, TPR argued that TOMA should protect the public's practical ability to observe deliberations and hold officials accountable, not just the technical availability of proceedings. The testimony addressed the growing practice of holding workshops, strategic planning sessions, and other meetings at locations that can create substantial obstacles to attendance.
TPR urged lawmakers to establish a clear presumption that meetings subject to the Act occur within a political subdivision's territorial boundaries, while recognizing that disasters, emergencies, and other unusual circumstances may justify meeting elsewhere. Any such departure, TPR recommended, should be supported by a publicly available finding explaining why relocation was necessary. The aim was a general rule with limited, accountable exceptions rather than an absolute prohibition.
Measured against that framework, HB 913 captures the core principle that local governments should ordinarily meet within the communities they represent, and HB 694 adds flexibility through its 10-mile allowance and evacuation exception. Neither bill requires officials to document and publicly justify a departure from the rule. That matters because a geographic restriction can stop the most extreme cases of inaccessible meetings without ensuring that every relocation is explained to the public.
Practical and Legal Implications
The strongest argument for both bills is that local officials conduct public business on behalf of residents, and those residents should have a reasonable opportunity to observe the deliberations that shape their taxes, spending, regulations, and infrastructure. A meeting held a hundred miles or more away may remain technically open while imposing real barriers: travel costs, work schedules, family responsibilities, and transportation limits can all make attendance unrealistic. A location requirement reduces the chance that distant venues will limit public scrutiny, whether by design or not. Bastrop shows how a meeting can satisfy every procedural requirement and still raise legitimate questions about access.
Distance is not the only factor, though. A meeting inside city limits can still be hard to attend because of limited parking, inadequate seating, inaccessible facilities, inconvenient scheduling, or short notice. A meeting just outside a boundary may be more accessible than one at the far end of a large county or special district. A boundary rule provides a clear legal standard, but it addresses one component of accessibility rather than every transparency concern.
It is also worth noting what the bills would not change. Neither would replace the broader Act. Governmental bodies would remain subject to its provisions on notice, open deliberation, closed meetings, and other safeguards. Meeting within the boundaries would not by itself establish compliance with those requirements, and a meeting outside the permitted area could raise a separate compliance issue even if its notice was proper. Neither bill creates a standalone enforcement mechanism, so remedies would fall under the existing statutory framework.
The bills' most significant practical effect may fall on workshops, retreats, and strategic planning sessions, which local governing bodies often hold away from their usual meeting rooms to discuss long-term priorities, budgets, and operations. These sessions may involve no final votes, but they can shape the decisions later presented for approval. Under the Act, whether a gathering is a meeting depends on the statutory definitions and the circumstances, not on whether officials call it a retreat or a workshop, and the absence of a vote does not by itself place substantive deliberations outside the law.
HB 913 and HB 694 would therefore reach off-site workshops and retreats that qualify as meetings. Neither bill expands the definition of a meeting, however, so a gathering outside that definition would not become covered because of the new location rules. Regulating where public meetings occur is a separate question from deciding which gatherings must comply with the Act in the first place.
What It Means for the 90th Legislative Session
The two bills suggest local government transparency might remain on the agenda in the 90th Legislative Session, and they show how a single local controversy can produce statewide legislation. Although Bastrop was the catalyst, the bills would apply to cities, counties, school districts, and other political subdivisions throughout Texas, whether or not they have ever met outside their jurisdictions.
The case for both is straightforward: public officials should conduct the public's business where the public can reasonably reach it. Their differences, though, could prompt debate over how far the state should go in prescribing local operations. Supporters of a strict rule may argue that broad exceptions would let officials keep relocating meetings away from their communities. Others may contend that an inflexible statewide mandate would burden smaller jurisdictions, geographically unusual districts, and governments responding to emergencies. The real debate may center less on whether meetings should be accessible than on how lawmakers define reasonable exceptions.
Both bills remain at the introductory stage and would need to complete the legislative process before becoming law.
Key Takeaways
HB 913 sets the stricter standard, requiring meetings inside a political subdivision's boundaries with no emergency exception. HB 694 permits meetings up to 10 miles outside those boundaries and adds a narrow countywide evacuation exception. A rigid rule may stop officials from meeting at distant locations but could cause problems when local facilities are unavailable; a flexible one accommodates those cases but lets officials meet elsewhere without explaining why.
The purpose of the Texas Open Meetings Act is not merely to keep government proceedings technically open. It is to preserve the public's ability to observe the conduct of public business and hold officials accountable. The challenge for lawmakers in the 90th Legislative Session will be writing clear, enforceable standards that protect that principle without unnecessarily restricting legitimate government operations.
Support Our Work
Texas Policy Research relies on generous donors across Texas. If you found this helpful, please consider supporting our efforts.
Donate TodayStay in the Loop
Subscribe for occasional emails with new research, event details, and ways to engage with Texas policy.
Subscribe for Updates